为什么你的定语从句越写越啰嗦?

改过几百篇作文后,我发现了中国学生最顽固的习惯之一:每个名词后面都要加一句 “which is…” 或 “that are…”

比如:

  • “a rule which was introduced last year”
  • “the company that is based in Beijing”
  • “people who are living in cities”

每一个都对,但每一个都可以更简洁

英语母语者的习惯是:能省略 “which/that + be” 的时候,绝对不写。今天我们从《金融时报》一篇关于俄罗斯体育禁赛的报道中,学习4个定语从句简化技巧。

FT 原文段落

Russia’s four-year ban from global sporting events has been halved, in a move that will affect athletes competing at the next two Olympic Games, but could end the long-running fallout from its state-sponsored doping scandal.

The Court of Arbitration for Sport, a Swiss body considered the ultimate arbiter for global sports disputes, ruled on Thursday that wide-ranging sanctions applied on Russia by the World Anti-Doping Agency should be upheld.

The ruling covers the next two Olympics — the summer games in Tokyo scheduled to take place next year, and the 2022 Winter games in Beijing — as well as other big sporting events such as the 2022 World Cup in Qatar.

俄罗斯为期四年的全球体育禁赛令被减半,此举将会影响参加未来两届奥运会的运动员,但也可能结束该国政府支持的兴奋剂丑闻带来的长期影响。被视为全球体育争端最终仲裁机构、位于瑞士的国际体育仲裁法庭裁定,维持世界反兴奋剂机构对俄罗斯实施的广泛制裁。这一裁决涵盖即将举行的两届奥运会——定于明年在东京举行的夏季奥运会和2022年在北京举行的冬季奥运会。

这段英文非常典型——全文一共只有1-2个完整的 “which/that” 引导词,但简化后的定语从句却出现了6次以上。这不是巧合:这就是母语者的默认写法。


技巧一:过去分词简化(最常见,占40%用例)

规则: “which/that + was/were + 过去分词” → 直接去掉引导词和 be 动词,保留过去分词。

FT原文:

  • sanctions **applied** on Russia(← sanctions which were applied on Russia)
  • a Swiss body **considered** the ultimate arbiter(← a Swiss body which is considered the ultimate arbiter)
  • the summer games **scheduled** to take place next year(← the summer games which are scheduled to take place…)

对比表格:

学生写法(啰嗦)升级写法(地道)
The rule which was introduced last year took effect.The rule introduced last year took effect.
Students who are taught by experienced teachers perform better.Students taught by experienced teachers perform better.
A report which was published today shows rising costs.A report published today shows rising costs.

模板: [名词] + [过去分词] + [剩余部分]

跨主题例句(科技类作文):

The algorithm developed by the research team achieved 98% accuracy. (← The algorithm which was developed by the research team achieved 98% accuracy.)


技巧二:现在分词简化(第二常见,占30%用例)

规则: “which/that/who + 主动态动词” → 去掉引导词,动词变为 -ing 形式。

FT原文:

  • athletes **competing** at the next two Olympic Games(← athletes who are competing at the next…)
  • bodies **including** the International Olympic Committee(← bodies which include the International Olympic Committee…)

💡 注意:只有当从句动词是主动态(doing)时才能用现在分词简化。如果是被动态(be done),用技巧一。

对比表格:

学生写法(啰嗦)升级写法(地道)
People who live in big cities face more pressure.People living in big cities face more pressure.
A company that offers remote work attracts more talent.A company offering remote work attracts more talent.
Students who study abroad often become more independent.Students studying abroad often become more independent.

模板: [名词] + [V-ing] + [剩余部分]

跨主题例句(环境类作文):

Countries facing the worst water shortages have started investing in desalination technology. (← Countries that face the worst water shortages…)


技巧三:非限制性逗号简化(占20%用例)

规则: , which + be + 形容词/分词, + 形容词/分词(去掉 which is,保留逗号和后面的内容)

FT原文并不直接包含这个格式,但我们可以从类似结构中推导: 假如原文写的是 “CAS, which is based in Switzerland, ruled…” → 简化后就是 “CAS, based in Switzerland, ruled…”

虽然没有完全匹配的例句,但这个技能非常实用——学生经常在 “which is located/founded/known” 上浪费字。

对比表格:

学生写法(啰嗦)升级写法(地道)
Shanghai, which is known as the financial hub of China, attracts global talent.Shanghai, known as the financial hub of China, attracts global talent.
The company, which was founded in 2010, has grown rapidly.The company, founded in 2010, has grown rapidly.

模板: [主语], [形容词/分词短语], [谓语+剩余部分]

⚠️ 注意:非限制性定语(逗号后的修饰)不能省略。如果你去掉逗号,意思会改变。简化的只是 “which is/was” 这部分,不是整个从句。


技巧四:破折号插入简化(高阶,占10%)

规则: — which/that + be + 过去分词 —— 过去分词 —

FT原文中的破折号结构:

The ruling covers the next two Olympics — the summer games scheduled to take place next year — as well as other big sporting events…

这里的 scheduled to take place 本身就是简化后的形式(省略了 which are)。FT 作者进一步用破折号把它作插入语处理,形成一种更紧凑的节奏。

对比表格:

学生写法(啰嗦)升级写法(地道)
The latest policy — which was announced last week — has caused debate.The latest policy — announced last week — has caused debate.
Her final project — which was completed in just one month — won first prize.Her final project — completed in just one month — won first prize.

模板: [名词] — [过去分词 + 修饰语] — [谓语+剩余部分]

💡 破折号比逗号更有”强调感”——它告诉读者”接下来的信息是重点关注的内容”。


实战练习:把下面这段改写简洁

学生版(未简化):

The experiment which was designed by Professor Wang, who is a leading scientist, produced results which were considered remarkable. The data which was collected over three years supports a theory which has been debated for decades.

升级版(应用4个技巧后):

The experiment designed by Professor Wang, a leading scientist, produced results considered remarkable. The data collected over three years supports a theory debated for decades.

从 34 个词变成 25 个词,减少 26%,每个信息点都更清晰。

写作建议

三步自查法:

  1. 第一步: 写完一段后,找到所有 “which/that/who + be” → 问自己:能不能直接删掉?
  2. 第二步: 找所有 “which/that/who + 主动词” → 问自己:能不能改成 V-ing?
  3. 第三步: 检查简化后意思是否改变——过去分词表被动/完成,现在分词表主动/进行,不要搞混。

把这4个技巧写在便利贴上,贴在你的书桌前。下次写作文时,写完检查一遍,看看能消灭几个 “which is”。


厦门灯塔 · 专业英语作文逐句批改 | 微信 linstudio799 专注中高考/雅思写作 · 逐句精批 + 逻辑重构 + 母语级升级